Legal Challenges in the Indian Healthcare Industry

Share on:

Introduction

The Indian healthcare sector has undergone major restructuring and transformation in the last few decades. It is one of the largest sectors in the country, contributing majorly to the economy and employing millions. However, despite rapid advances in healthcare infrastructure, services, and technology, the Indian healthcare system is confronted with numerous legal challenges. These challenges are multifaceted and involve the complexity of regulations, medical malpractice issues, ethics, patient rights, and increasing concerns over public health and access to healthcare services. In this article, we will discuss the legal challenges in the Indian Healthcare Industry in brief. 

Regulatory Framework

Probably the major legal challenges India's healthcare sector faces include how to traverse through the rather dense regulatory maze that surrounds this health sector. Healthcare in India is governed by a plethora of laws, regulations, and guidelines, often contradictory or ambiguous. Both the federal and state governments control the healthcare sector, creating a fragmented framework that can be challenging for healthcare professionals to understand. For Instance,

• the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, deals with the manufacturing, sale, and distribution of drugs and cosmetics in India, “An Act to regulate the import, manufacture, distribution and sale of drugs.”
• the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956, provides for the governance of the medical profession and the registration of medical practitioners, “An Act to provide for the reconstitution of the Medical Council of India, and the maintenance of a Medical Register for India and for matters connected therewith.”
• the National Medical Commission (NMC) Act, 2019, replaced the erstwhile MCI (Medical Council of India) and brought far-reaching changes to medical education and practice, “An Act to provide for a medical education system that improves access to quality and affordable medical education, ensures availability of adequate and high quality medical professionals in all parts of the country; that promotes equitable and universal healthcare that encourages community health perspective and makes services of medical professionals accessible to all the citizens; that promotes national health goals; that encourages medical professionals to adopt latest medical research in their work and to contribute to research; that has an objective periodic and transparent assessment of medical institutions and facilitates maintenance of a medical register for India and enforces high ethical standards in all aspects of medical services; that is flexible to adapt to changing needs and has an effective grievance redressal mechanism and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.” 

However, these laws often face challenges in enforcement due to varying levels of implementation across states, which creates inconsistencies in healthcare delivery. Moreover, healthcare providers need to abide by the clinical establishment laws, which vary from state to state. Most states have enacted the Clinical Establishment (Registration and Regulation) Act, 2010. This act attempts to regulate the working of hospitals and nursing homes, “An Act to provide for the registration and regulation of clinical establishments in the country and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto.” However, in the absence of a common national law, there is much confusion and, hence, lack of compliance often by private healthcare establishments, whose branches are in various states.

Medical Negligence and Malpractice

Medical negligence and malpractice are some of the prime legal hurdles faced by the Indian healthcare sector. As more and more healthcare facilities emerge and the number of medical professionals rises, incidents of medical negligence have become a growing concern for patient safety and the quality of care. Medical negligence refers to the failure of healthcare providers to exercise the level of care and skill expected in a given situation, leading to injury or harm to a patient. In India, the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, provides a legal right for patients to sue healthcare providers for negligence. The legal process is slow and burdensome in medical malpractice cases. Legal battles over medical negligence are lengthy and expensive, and this deters patients from seeking justice. Many times, hospitals and medical professionals face both civil and criminal charges, which are hard to defend against. Many a time, medical malpractice laws in India have been criticized for their inefficiency. Though the Consumer Protection Act gives redress to victims of medical negligence, the judicial process invariably becomes lengthy, with many cases still unresolved for years. Furthermore, these legal actions are frequently complicated by the absence of consistency in establishing the burden of proof and what constitutes negligence.

Patient Rights and Privacy Concerns

One of the chief aspects of healthcare law is the right to privacy and confidentiality. Patient privacy has emerged as a prominent issue in India with the widespread use of digital health technologies, electronic medical records, and telemedicine. To safeguard patients' data in the digital world, the Health Ministry has drafted a Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019. Unfortunately, the existing legal framework that protects patient data is still inadequate, while breaches of confidentiality prove to be a major challenge. 

The COVID-19 pandemic has created a need for clear guidelines and legal structures that protect patient information, especially in telemedicine and online consultations. Healthcare providers ought to try to maintain an adequate level of confidentiality while storing patient data and must obtain proper consent prior to sharing any sensitive information about his or her medical condition. There are concerns that the lack of strict data protection laws and regulatory oversight in India could allow unauthorized access to patient records, especially when patients are seeking remote consultations or medical advice. 

Informed consent is another issue. Oftentimes, healthcare agencies may not fully inform the patient of the risks and benefits associated with relevant treatment procedures. This inadequate informed consent could be the basis of legal action brought against the physician for medical negligence. Ensuring that patients understand their treatment options and have the opportunity to make informed decisions is an ongoing challenge in the legal landscape of Indian healthcare.

Access to Affordable Healthcare and Legal Liabilities

While there have been good developments in the Indian healthcare sector, affordability continues to be a challenge in rural areas. The legal issues regarding pricing and availability of essential medicines, medical services, and treatments are sometimes a source of tension among Cities and Villages with respect to accessibility. A major concern over the growing cost of healthcare services, leading inevitably to the postponement of care for the economically disadvantaged, is yet another equity challenge. As an added result of the public health sector, often, the service quality and healthcare facilities are pretty unsatisfactory. It thus remains to the private sector that those who could pay would enjoy these services, resulting in unequal rights for specific parts of the population regarding equal health care while considering health a right under the Indian Constitution. 

Issues also abound with the law concerning the pricing and regulation of medicines. The government regulates the prices of essential drugs through the National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority (NPPA), but this regulation is, for most practical purposes, unenforceable upon various pharmaceutical companies alleged to violate the price control standards. However, whenever general price hikes do occur, the life-saving drugs often suffer the hardest price gouges, putting them well beyond the financial capacity of a large sector of the population. The exceptions to these cases arise largely from the slow nature of legal proceedings and almost nonexistent accountability for pharmaceutical companies practicing violation of pricing laws.

Role of Technology 

The integration of technology in healthcare has dramatically changed the dynamics of the industry in India. There are, however, legal challenges that emerge with every new technology. Whether it is the regulation of telemedicine, AI assistance in diagnostics and treatment, or the legal implications of robot surgeries, these are some of the areas of concern. Telemedicine is a benefit in itself, but the regulations that govern it are still inconsistent. Telemedicine Practice Guidelines are issued by the Medical Council of India. There is some sort of structure here, but such guidelines are felt to be meager in meeting the fast changes in telemedicine technologies. Again, AI-driven healthcare systems are raising ethical and legal issues with regard to liability in case of a mistake or malfunction. For example, if a diagnostic algorithm misdiagnoses a patient's condition, would the liability rest with the health worker, software developer, or the hospital?

Conclusion

The legal challenges the Indian healthcare industry faces may be regulatory, ethical, or financial and are thus complex and multifaceted. As the industry continues to grow and evolve, lawmakers, healthcare providers, and patients need to collaborate to ensure that the healthcare system is equitable, efficient, and transparent. In order to uphold all contemporary developments in the Indian healthcare industry, future legal challenges will depend on the tricky balance of innovation, regulation, and patient rights.